Most criminal cases never reach a jury. In 2012 the US Supreme Court noted that 97% of federal convictions and 94% of state convictions came from guilty pleas. So for most people charged with a crime, the real questions are practical ones: whether you’ll be held in jail while the case is pending, what the prosecutor can prove, what deal is on the table, and whether your lawyer has had time to test the evidence before you decide.
This guide follows a case from arrest to sentencing, explains the difference between a felony and a misdemeanor and between state and federal charges, and covers what to say (and not say) to police, who gets a public defender, and how private defense lawyers charge.
Felony or misdemeanor: why the label matters
The basic dividing line is the maximum punishment. In federal law, any crime that can carry more than a year in prison is a felony, and anything with a maximum of a year or less is a misdemeanor. Most states draw the line in a similar place, though they name and grade offenses their own way. Felonies are usually served in state or federal prison, misdemeanors in a county jail.
| Federal class | Maximum prison term |
|---|---|
| Class A felony | Life or death |
| Class B felony | 25 years or more |
| Class C felony | 10 to under 25 years |
| Class D felony | 5 to under 10 years |
| Class E felony | More than 1 year, under 5 |
| Class A misdemeanor | More than 6 months, up to 1 year |
| Class B misdemeanor | More than 30 days, up to 6 months |
| Class C misdemeanor | More than 5 days, up to 30 days |
| Infraction | 5 days or less, or no jail |
The label affects more than the sentence. A felony conviction can cost you the right to own a gun, some professional licenses and certain jobs, and for noncitizens it can carry serious immigration consequences. Some offenses can go either way: the same conduct may be charged as a misdemeanor or a felony depending on the amount of money involved, the injury caused, or the defendant’s record. A DUI, for example, usually starts as a misdemeanor and becomes a felony with enough prior convictions or a serious injury; our DUI guide covers how that works.
Talking to the police: what Miranda does and doesn’t do
The Miranda warnings come from a 1966 Supreme Court decision. Before police question someone who is in custody, they must say that the person has the right to stay silent, that anything said can be used in court, that they can have a lawyer present, and that one will be appointed if they can’t afford it. If police skip the warnings, the usual remedy is that prosecutors can’t use those statements to prove guilt. It doesn’t mean the case gets thrown out.
Two limits trip people up. First, the warnings apply to custodial interrogation. A casual conversation at your front door, or questions at a traffic stop before any arrest, may not count, and what you say there can be used. Second, staying quiet isn’t enough to stop questioning. In Berghuis v. Thompkins (2010), a suspect sat mostly silent for about two hours and 45 minutes of questioning, then began answering yes-or-no questions; the Court held that he never invoked his rights because he never clearly said he was invoking them, and his answer was admitted.
If you’re questioned about a crime, say it out loud and plainly: “I’m going to remain silent. I want a lawyer.” Then stop talking, including to cellmates. Be polite, don’t physically resist, and don’t try to explain your side. Giving your name and showing ID when the law requires it is a separate matter from answering questions about the case.
How a criminal case moves
The steps below are typical. Names and timing differ by state, and a misdemeanor can move through several of them in a single court date.
Arrest and booking
An arrest can happen on a warrant a judge has already signed, or on the spot when an officer has probable cause. At booking, police take fingerprints and a photo, inventory your property, and check for other warrants. For minor offenses, many places issue a citation and release you with a court date instead.
First appearance, bail and pretrial release
If you were arrested without a warrant, a judge has to decide whether there was probable cause to hold you, generally within 48 hours. After that, the government has to show a real emergency to justify the delay, and a weekend doesn’t count. At or near the first appearance, the court also decides whether you go home while the case is pending and on what terms: release on your promise to return, release with conditions such as check-ins or electronic monitoring, money bail, or detention without bail in more serious cases.
Bail practice differs a lot by state. Illinois became the first state to abolish cash bail entirely on September 18, 2023, under its Pretrial Fairness Act; judges there decide release and detention at hearings instead of setting a dollar amount. In federal court, a judge can hold a detention hearing, and people who are released are usually supervised by a pretrial services officer.
Calls and video visits from jail are usually recorded, and prosecutors can listen to them. Don’t discuss the facts of your case with anyone except your lawyer, and don’t ask family to contact witnesses or the alleged victim. Doing so can lead to new charges or tighter release conditions.
Formal charges: grand jury or preliminary hearing
Someone other than the police has to decide whether there’s enough evidence to go forward on a serious charge. In the federal system, felony charges come through a grand jury indictment unless the defendant waives it, as the Fifth Amendment requires. The grand jury hears the prosecutor’s evidence in private, and the defense doesn’t present its side.
Many states instead let the prosecutor file a charging document called an information, after a preliminary hearing where a judge decides whether there’s probable cause. The defense can cross-examine witnesses at a preliminary hearing, which makes it an early look at the government’s case. In California, once a judge holds you to answer on a felony, the prosecutor has 15 days to file the information or the case must be dismissed unless there’s good cause.
Arraignment and discovery
At arraignment you hear the formal charges and enter a plea, almost always “not guilty” at this stage, even if you expect to make a deal later. A not-guilty plea keeps your options open while your lawyer gets the evidence.
That evidence comes through discovery: police reports, witness statements, video, lab results, phone extractions. Prosecutors also have a constitutional duty to turn over evidence that’s favorable to the defense. Your lawyer may file motions to suppress evidence obtained through an illegal search or an improper interrogation. Winning one of those can sink the prosecution’s case or change the plea offer.
Plea bargaining
A plea deal usually means pleading guilty to a lesser charge, to fewer counts, or in exchange for a recommended sentence. Because so many cases end this way, the Supreme Court has held that the right to effective counsel applies to plea negotiations too. In Missouri v. Frye, it said defense lawyers generally must tell clients about formal plea offers from the prosecution; a lawyer who let an offer expire without telling the client fell below the constitutional standard.
The decision to plead guilty is yours, not your lawyer’s. Before accepting, ask what the conviction will mean beyond the sentence: for your license, your job, your housing, your immigration status, and whether it can ever be cleared from your record.
Trial and sentencing
At trial, the prosecution must prove every element of the charge beyond a reasonable doubt. You don’t have to testify, and the prosecutor can’t argue that your silence shows guilt. If you’re convicted, or plead guilty, sentencing follows. In federal cases and in many state felony cases, a probation officer prepares a presentence report on your background and the offense, and the judge considers it along with arguments from both sides. Crime victims can usually speak at sentencing.
Speedy trial rules
The Sixth Amendment guarantees a speedy trial, and most jurisdictions add specific deadlines by statute. The federal Speedy Trial Act requires an indictment or information within 30 days of arrest, and a trial within 70 days of the indictment or first appearance, whichever is later. It also says trial can’t start less than 30 days after the defendant first appears with counsel unless the defendant agrees in writing. Those numbers sound fast, but the act excludes many kinds of delay: time spent on pretrial motions, competency evaluations, and continuances a judge finds serve the ends of justice.
State rules vary. California requires a felony trial within 60 days of arraignment on the information or indictment. For a misdemeanor, it’s 30 days after arraignment or plea if you’re in custody and 45 days if you’re out. Defendants often waive time, generally or to a specific date, because their lawyers need longer to investigate. If you’re in custody and the evidence is weak, insisting on your speedy trial rights can be a strategy; if you’re out and the defense needs work, waiving time is often the better choice. That call belongs with your lawyer.
State or federal charges
Most crimes are prosecuted by states: assault, theft, burglary, DUI, most drug possession. Federal charges cover conduct that crosses state lines or touches federal interests, such as mail and wire fraud, tax crimes, federal drug trafficking, child exploitation online, and crimes on federal property. Some conduct can be charged in either system, or both.
Federal cases feel different. They’re usually investigated for months before anyone is charged, so the government often has its evidence lined up on day one. Sentencing follows the federal sentencing guidelines and, for some crimes, mandatory minimums. If you get a letter saying you’re the target of a federal investigation, or agents ask to speak with you, get a lawyer with federal experience before you respond.
Your right to a lawyer, and who gets a public defender
In Gideon v. Wainwright (1963), the Supreme Court held that a state has to provide a lawyer to a felony defendant who can’t afford one. Clarence Gideon had asked a Florida judge for counsel and been refused; he defended himself and got five years. Later cases set the rule for lesser charges. A court can’t actually jail someone who was denied appointed counsel, and in 2002 the Court said that also covers a suspended jail sentence that could be triggered later. If the judge plans a fine-only sentence, the federal constitutional right doesn’t apply, though many states give broader rights by law.
Public defenders are full-time lawyers paid by the government to represent people who qualify. Some counties use contract lawyers or appointed private attorneys instead. Each jurisdiction sets its own financial test, and you’ll usually fill out a form about your income and assets at or before the first appearance. Public defenders often carry heavy caseloads, but they handle criminal cases every day and know the local prosecutors and judges well.
What a private criminal defense lawyer costs
Criminal defense lawyers can’t take cases on contingency. The ABA’s model ethics rules, which most states follow, bar a fee in a criminal case that depends on the outcome. That leaves two main structures:
- A flat fee, common for misdemeanors, DUIs and simpler felonies. It’s often split into stages, with one price through a plea or dismissal and a second, larger price if the case goes to trial. Ask exactly what’s included: motions hearings, investigators, expert witnesses, an appeal.
- Hourly billing against a retainer, common in serious felonies and federal cases. You pay a deposit up front, the lawyer bills time against it, and you’re asked to top it up as it runs down. Ask for the hourly rates of everyone who’ll work on the file and how often you’ll get a bill.
Under the same ethics rules, a fee has to be reasonable, and the lawyer should tell you how it’s calculated, preferably in writing, before or soon after starting the work. If a flat fee is called nonrefundable, ask what happens if you need to change lawyers partway through. Some states, Arizona and Ohio among them, restrict fees described as earned on receipt unless the client is told in writing that a refund may still be owed. Prices vary widely with the charge, the county and the lawyer’s experience, so get a written quote from more than one office if time allows.
Check any lawyer’s license and discipline history on your state bar’s website. If you don’t have a name, your state or local bar’s lawyer referral service can match you with a defense lawyer, sometimes for a reduced-fee first consultation; the ABA lists those services by state. If you think you’re under investigation but haven’t been charged, that’s the time to call. A lawyer can sometimes do the most good before charges are filed.
Sources
- Missouri v. Frye, 566 U.S. 134 (2012)
- 18 U.S.C. § 3559: Sentencing classification of offenses
- US Courts: Miranda v. Arizona overview (archived)
- Berghuis v. Thompkins, 560 U.S. 370 (2010)
- County of Riverside v. McLaughlin, 500 U.S. 44 (1991)
- Illinois Supreme Court: Preparations for the end of cash bail
- US Attorney’s Office, District of Alaska: The federal criminal justice system
- US Constitution, Fifth Amendment
- Cal. Penal Code § 1382
- 18 U.S.C. § 3161: Speedy Trial Act time limits
- US Courts: Facts and case summary, Gideon v. Wainwright
- Alabama v. Shelton, 535 U.S. 654 (2002)
- ABA Model Rule 1.5: Fees
- ABA Family Advocate (Winter 2026): Ethics of attorney fees
- ABA Lawyer Referral Directory